Eviction Collection Agency: Reviews & Best Companies

Key Takeaways

• Eviction collection agencies specialize in recovering unpaid rent from former tenants through legal and ethical methods, including skip tracing, credit reporting, and professional communication that respects tenant rights while protecting landlord interests. 
• The contingency-based fee model eliminates upfront costs for landlords, as you only pay when the agency successfully recovers funds—typically 10–25% of collected amounts, depending on debt age and complexity.
• Some of the leading eviction collection agencies include Southwest Recovery Services, Prodigal Technology, Advanced Credit Bureau, and Fair Capital Group.
• Selecting the right agency requires evaluating specialization in rental property collections, skip tracing capabilities, legal compliance, transparent reporting systems, and verified testimonials from property managers.
• Southwest Recovery Services stands out with over 20 years of specialized rental collection experience, AI-guided tracking across communication channels, no-collection no-fee pricing, and a relationship-focused approach that recovers rent while maintaining professional standards.

The Need for Eviction Collection Agencies

When tenants vacate your property owing back rent, the financial impact extends far beyond lost revenue. Unpaid rent disrupts cash flow, increases vacancy costs, and adds administrative burdens that distract from managing your other properties effectively. This is where eviction collection agencies become invaluable partners for landlords and property management companies.

An eviction collection agency focuses on recovering delinquent rent payments and related costs from former tenants who have moved out, often following eviction proceedings. Unlike general debt collectors who handle a wide range of consumer debts, these specialized agencies understand the unique challenges of rental property collections, from navigating state-specific landlord-tenant laws to locating tenants who’ve moved without forwarding addresses.

They bring professional expertise, dedicated resources, and systematic processes that most landlords simply can’t replicate internally. More importantly, they handle the uncomfortable but necessary task of persistent follow-up, allowing you to focus on managing your properties and maintaining relationships with current tenants.

Core Services Provided by Rental Collection Agencies

Specialized collectors trained in rental debt recovery contact former tenants through multiple channels like phone calls, letters, emails, and text messages. They also use professional communication strategies that encourage payment without escalating conflicts unnecessarily. These collectors understand tenant psychology and know how to negotiate payment arrangements that work for both parties.

One of the biggest challenges in eviction collections is finding tenants who’ve moved without leaving contact information. Professional agencies employ skip tracers who use proprietary databases, public records, and investigative techniques to locate former tenants. This capability potentially increases recovery success rates on accounts that would otherwise be written off as uncollectible.

The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act and state-specific collection laws create complex compliance requirements, but professional agencies ensure all communication follows proper procedures and maintain detailed documentation of every collection attempt, which becomes critical if legal action becomes necessary.

Top Eviction Collection Agencies

Several agencies have established strong reputations in the rental property collection space, each offering distinct strengths and service approaches.

Southwest Recovery Services (SWRS)

With over 20 years of focused experience in rental collections, we at Southwest Recovery Services (SWRS) have built a national reputation for ethical, effective debt recovery. We operate exclusively on a contingency basis with no upfront costs, ensuring you pay nothing unless we successfully recover funds on your behalf.

What distinguishes us is our AI-guided tracking system that monitors every account across phone calls, emails, text messages, and traditional mail, ensuring consistent follow-up without manual tracking burden. We also maintain 12 offices across six states, providing nationwide coverage while offering personalized service. 

Our veteran collectors use respectful, professional communication that pursues debt recovery without creating unnecessary conflicts. Property managers consistently praise us for transparent reporting through client portals, responsive account management, and recovery results that exceed expectations.

We are also a recognized member of National Association of Residential Property Managers (NARPM), reflecting our commitment to industry standards, ethical practices, and long-term partnership with property management professionals.

Other Notable Agencies

Here are other notable eviction collections agencies: 

• Prodigal Technology leverages AI-driven automation to boost debt collection efficiency, compliance, and customer engagement. Its platform enables collectors to communicate with empathy while automating routine tasks, accelerating rent recovery after evictions and improving results through predictive analytics and real-time compliance monitoring.
• Advanced Credit Bureau specializes in rent and eviction collections for property management firms, offering tailored solutions that address industry-specific billing and legal requirements. Their deep expertise helps landlords recover unpaid rent while preserving professional relationships and staying compliant with housing regulations.
• Fair Capital Group emphasizes transparent, ethical collection practices and maintains strong partnerships with major credit bureaus. Their process ensures accurate reporting of unpaid rent, protects client reputations, and provides effective negotiation strategies to resolve eviction-related debts respectfully and efficiently.

How to Choose the Right Eviction Collection Agency

Selecting an eviction collection partner requires careful evaluation of several critical factors that directly impact your recovery success and ongoing business reputation.

Industry Specialization & Expertise

Agencies that focus specifically on rental debt understand landlord-tenant laws, eviction processes, and the unique dynamics of housing-related collections. This specialization matters because rental debt differs significantly from commercial invoices or consumer credit card debt in both legal treatment and recovery strategies.

Contingency-Based Fee Structure

The contingency-based model is standard in eviction collections. You pay nothing upfront, and the agency earns a percentage only when they successfully recover funds. According to industry standards, contingency fees typically range from 10–25% depending on the debt’s age, amount, and complexity. This pay-on-success model eliminates your financial risk and aligns the agency’s incentives directly with your recovery goals.

Skip Tracing Capabilities

Since many former tenants relocate to avoid debt, effective skip tracing separates successful agencies from those with poor recovery rates. Ask potential agencies about their skip tracing tools and success rates in locating relocated tenants.

Compliance & Regulatory Record

Request information about the agency’s compliance protocols, training programs for collectors, and whether they’ve faced regulatory actions related to collection practices. Agencies with strong compliance records protect you from potential liability and maintain professional standards that preserve your property management reputation.

Client Testimonials and Track Record

Look for agencies with documented testimonials from other landlords and property management companies. Pay particular attention to reviews that mention recovery rates, communication quality, and how well the agency handled difficult accounts.

Why Southwest Recovery Services is the Best for Rental Debt Recovery

When internal efforts fail to produce results, partnering with a specialized agency that understands rental property collections becomes essential. At Southwest Recovery Services, we bring unique capabilities that directly address the challenges property managers face with unpaid rent.

Our AI-guided tracking system ensures no account falls through the cracks. It monitors every promise to pay, tracks communication across all channels, and triggers appropriate escalation automatically. This approach, combined with the daily involvement of our founder, creates accountability that translates into better recovery rates.

We operate on a contingency model, meaning that you pay nothing upfront until we successfully recover your funds. Our veteran collectors understand that even when pursuing unpaid debts, professionalism matters. That’s why they use persistent yet respectful communication that recovers rent without damaging your property management reputation in the community.

We provide clear reporting on account status and outcomes through accessible client portals, so you always know where your collections stand. This transparency, combined with responsive account management, creates partnerships that extend beyond single collection accounts.

Request a Free Quote Today!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

When should I send an account to an eviction collection agency instead of handling it myself?

Consider engaging a collection agency when your direct attempts over 30–60 days have produced no response or payment. 

It’s also time to seek help if the tenant has vacated without leaving contact information, the debt amount justifies the effort (typically accounts over $500), or you lack the time and resources for persistent follow-up.

How much do eviction collection agencies typically charge?

Most reputable eviction collection agencies operate on a contingency basis, charging 10–25% of successfully recovered funds depending on the debt’s age, amount, and complexity. 

This pay-on-success model means you pay nothing upfront and only share a portion of what the agency actually collects. 

Can collection agencies report unpaid rent to credit bureaus?

Yes, collection agencies can report unpaid rental debt to credit bureaus such as Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion. This negative reporting impacts the tenant’s credit score, which creates financial incentive to resolve the debt and alerts future landlords about payment history. 

However, agencies must follow specific procedures under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, including proper verification and providing tenants opportunities to dispute inaccurate information.

What happens if a tenant claims they don’t owe the money or disputes the amount?

When tenants dispute debts, reputable collection agencies pause collection efforts and request documentation from you to verify the amount owed. This is why maintaining complete records is critical. 

The agency will review your documentation and respond appropriately to the tenant’s dispute, protecting both parties and ensuring compliance with the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act.

How does Southwest Recovery Services’ approach differ from other collection agencies?

With over 20 years of debt collection experience, Southwest Recovery Services provides reliable, results-driven solutions for property managers nationwide. With 12 offices across six states and transparent client portals offering real-time updates, we deliver comprehensive collection services with no financial risk. 

Our proven track record of ethical practices and consistent performance has earned us recognition as a trusted partner for landlords seeking effective rent recovery.

*Note: Recovery rates mentioned are for general reference only and not guaranteed. Actual results vary by account and industry. Contact Southwest Recovery Services for a customized quote.